The Sanitized Mission trip

DOOR began hosting short-term mission/service groups in 1986. We were one of the first programs in the country to do so. Since that time the annual mission trip has become part of the life cycle of many if not most churches. Programs have sprung up all over the USA and around the world dedicated to filling this growing desire to participate in the annual short-term trip.

When I think back to the early days of this movement I am sometimes embarrassed by all the things we did wrong. More often than not we came into communities of need “knowing” how to fix all the problems. The good that was accomplished was often overshadowed by the paternalistic, racist and arrogant attitudes people came with.

I am glad to report that DOOR has learned from its past. We understand that God is already in the city. Before we can talk about bringing God into a community we first must understand where God already is. When it comes to differences we have learned that different is just different. People worship differently, eat differently, look different, come to faith differently, and express themselves differently. All of this is OK and a demonstration of the breadth and depth of the kingdom of God. When it comes to service, mission, and ministry, if it isn’t mutual then it probably isn’t something God is calling us to. This journey has been mind-blowing and faith-expanding.

There is a new trend that has me worried. I call it the sanitized mission trip. The desire to serve is alive and well. There is a recognition that ministry must be mutual. This is good. The problem is that we want mission and service to happen in a Disneyland type of atmosphere. We want an experience as long as it is safe and sanitized. Here is the rub. Experiencing different neighborhoods, cultures and people can be intimidating and even unpredictable. This does not always feel safe.

In 1992 I took a youth group to South Central Los Angeles 45 days after the riots. Just before we left on that trip I met with the parents. All of them were nervous. Many thought we should cancel the trip; some even pulled their children out of the trip. In spite of this a smaller group of us still went on the trip. Was it safe? Certainly not by “Disneyland” standards, but it was transformational. During this trip we discovered that the news media got some things right, for example a riot occurred. At the same time it got many things wrong. We discovered a South Central LA that was full of parents who wanted a good life for their children, street venders who could produce meals that five star restaurants would have trouble competing with, homeless people who wanted to talk, and merchants who wanted customers.

Was our trip safe? In one sense the answer is yes. No one had to go to the hospital. In another sense it was a very dangerous trip. We all walked away from South Central with a new pessimism for how the media reports the news, especially in urban communities. In addition our understanding of the kingdom of God was forever changed. At a personal level I came back to Denver and joined the board of a program called “DOOR.” A few years later I became the City Director for Denver and a few years after that our family moved from the suburbs to the city. Because of that trip, everything changed for me and my family.

If we ask safety questions to avoid silly and irresponsible behavior then I am all for asking the questions. Otherwise I am not sure that “safety” and “mission/service trip” belong in the same sentence. The call to deny ourselves and pick up the cross simply doesn’t create space for a sanitized mission trip.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under being wrong, Christian, church, church camp, culture, diversity, doubt, God questions, kingdom of heaven, ministry, multicultural, mutual trust, mutuality, service, service to others, short-term mission, transforming, urban ministry, urban tour

3 responses to “The Sanitized Mission trip

  1. Age

    Glenn

    This is unbelievable. I am currently working on my next blog titled “Mission Trip or Spring Break Training”. My mind is floored with this way of missions recently. Great blog, look for mine shortly to come. Ill keep you posted as I continue to read yours.

    Blessings Bro

  2. John T. Spencer

    When I worked for an innercity non-profit, we often experienced the paternalistic, racist attitudes of churches that wanted to be on work crew for a week. It felt like a sort-of suburban colonialism, where they would come in and offer all the right answers. But as much as it bothered me, I was more upset with the sense that within the barrio that I loved, the people were being used. It felt exploitative when suburbanites visited for an adventure, for a diversion, for something that would sound great in a story. I watched them pry very personal stories from very young children just to change a name and share the details in front of a white congregation. I heard them say things like, “I didn’t know how good I had it,” as if that was the reason for mission: to slum it up for a week in order to feel good about yourselves. They missed the beauty of the barrio. They missed the ways God was at work in the families that I knew.

    But . . .

    Sometimes they were humbled. Sometimes they came back, confused, in tears, but wanting to understand God’s heart for the poor. And it was in that place that they grew to love our community and see where God was at work.

    I came to the realization that you can’t hear the cry of the poor unless you put down the megaphone.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s